Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print Feed Feed

Carnival to pay $20 million fine for pollution, 'deliberate deception'

Jun 4, 2019 02:06 PM

The company, already serving five years of probation, is cited for 'major non-conformities'

Courtesy Wikipedia

The following is text of a news release from the U.S. Justice Department:

(WASHINGTON) — Princess Cruise Lines Ltd. and its parent, Carnival Cruise Lines & plc, have been ordered to pay a $20 million criminal penalty and will be subject to enhanced supervision after admitting to violations of probation attributable to senior Carnival management in a case in which Princess had already paid $40 million.

Princess was convicted and sentenced in April 2017, after pleading guilty to felony charges stemming from its deliberate dumping of oil-contaminated waste from one of its vessels and intentional acts to cover it up. While serving five years of probation, all Carnival-related cruise lines vessels eligible to trade in U.S. ports were required to comply with a court-approved and supervised environmental compliance plan (ECP), including audits by an independent company and oversight by a court-appointed monitor. Numerous violations have been identified by the company, the outside auditor, and the court’s monitor during the first two years of probation, including “major non-conformities” as defined by the ECP.

Carnival admitted it was guilty of committing six violations of probation. Two of the violations involved interfering with the court’s supervision of probation by sending undisclosed teams to ships to prepare them for the independent inspections required during probation. When this was first discovered in December 2017, U.S. District Court Judge Patricia Seitz directed that the practice cease and ordered additional inspections as a consequence. However, without seeking court approval, a second undisclosed program was started shortly thereafter. Documents filed in court showed that a purpose of the vessel visit programs was to avoid adverse findings during the inspections.

“This case demonstrates the importance of identifying and correcting compliance problems at their source. Carnival sought to avoid the discovery of problems during the audits rather than learn from them. Carnival’s deliberate deception undermined the court’s supervision of probation,” said Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Bossert Clark for the Justice Department’s Environment and Natural Resources Division. “I want to take this opportunity to thank and commend the Office of Probation and the court-appointed monitor for the close attention that they have devoted to this important matter post-conviction.” 

“A corporation is responsible to its shareholders and board of directors to be profitable, but not by breaking the law and destroying the very environment in which it navigates for profit,” said U.S. Attorney Ariana Fajardo Orshan for the Southern District of Florida. “Carnival’s failure to comply with the terms of its probation and later, its attempt to drown its deceit goes against the fiber of corporate compliance. The Office of Probation and the court-appointed monitor are to be commended for their attention to this matter.” 

Carnival’s chairman of the board, chief executive officer and chief financial officer attended the hearing pursuant to court’s order and were asked to personally pledge their commitment to correcting the company’s compliance issues and corporate culture. In addition, senior management of each operating cruise line of Carnival Corp. & plc were present for the court proceedings Monday.

The company admitted to other violations of probation including:

• Failing to establish a senior corporate officer as a corporate compliance manager with responsibility and sufficient authority for implementing new environmental measures required during probation;
• Contacting the Coast Guard seeking to re-define the definition of what constitutes a major non-conformity under the ECP without going through the required process and after the government had rejected the proposal and told the company to file a motion with the court if it wanted to pursue the issue;
• Deliberately falsifying environmental training records aboard two cruise ships; and
• Deliberately discharging plastic in Bahamian waters from Carnival Elation and failing to accurately record the illegal discharges. Prosecutors advised the court that this particular instance was an example of a more widespread problem, identified by the external audits, in failing to segregate plastic and non-food garbage from waste thrown overboard from numerous cruise ships.

Under the terms of the settlement, Carnival will do the following:

• Pay a $20 million criminal penalty;
• Issue a statement to all employees in which Carnival’s CEO accepts management’s responsibility for the probation violations;
• Restructure the company’s corporate compliance efforts, including appointing a new chief corporate compliance officer, creating an Executive Compliance Committee across all cruise lines, adding a new member to the board of directors with corporate compliance expertise, and train its board of directors;
• Pay up to $10 million per day if it does not meet deadlines for submitting and implementing needed changes to its corporate structure;
• Pay for 15 additional independent audits per year conducted by the third-party auditor and court-appointed monitor (on top of approximately 31 ship audits and six shore-side audits currently performed annually);
• Comply with new reporting requirements, including notifying the government and court of all future violations, and specifically identifying foreign violations and the country impacted; and
• Make major changes in how the company uses and disposes of plastic and other non-food waste to urgently address a problem on multiple vessels concerning illegal discharges of plastic mixed with other garbage.

The revised sentence imposed by Seitz also requires that Princess remain on probation for a period of three years.

Add your comment:
Edit Module